Thursday, April 29, 2010

Gender ordered ministry, part 2

In part one, with help from Ben Witherington III, I viewed the ministry of women in the book of Acts in a positive light. I now proceed to examine how some of the Pauline evidence is treated by an egalitarian, and discover that such evidence fails to weigh against the texts which restrict to men the roles of leading, teaching and preaching, in the gathered body of the church.

As a foil I use an
article by Dr C.D. Marshall, Was Paul a Sexist?, published in Reality Magazine. (Selected because it was on the recommended reading list for my original essay assignment.) My first criticism is that he characterises the position he wishes to oppose with the invidious label "Christian sexism", while he, on the other hand, aligns himself with the more positively labeled camp of "progressive evangelicals". Such labeling does no justice to the nuance and grace of the actual complementarian position. (See the Danvers Statement.)


Evidence from Paul

"I cannot believe for a moment that the radical apostle, who believed so passionately in liberty and who insisted so emphatically on the equality in Christ of Jew and Gentile, slave and free, male and female,3 would have wished the limitations placed on women in certain congregations to have been set in concrete for all time."

That's wishful thinking based on a facile appeal to Gal 3:28, a verse which has nothing to do with gender roles in the church. There's a distinction to be made between equality and role differences. Failure to recognise this constitutes an equivocation on the notion of equality in Christ. Correspondingly, the members of the Trinity are equally God, yet their roles are diverse, the Son being subject to the Father.

In context, the point of Gal 3:28 is that, despite external ethnic or social status, through faith in Christ no one has more or less favour or righteous standing with God, or is more or less the child of God according to the promise given to Abraham. It's a soteriological equality. To best learn about roles in the church we need to give precedence to those passages having a specifically ecclesiological concern and eschew reading between the lines of a passage having a primarily soteriological concern.

For example, germane to how the body of Christ is constituted is 1 Cor 12:12-31 which likens it to the human body - a united body of organs of equal value, yet having diverse roles which accord to what they are by divine design (vv. 17-18). So too, God composes and makes diverse appointments in the body of Christ (vv. 24, 28). Thus, the presumption ought to be that ministry roles are to be indexed to gender to the extent that gender is significant for what human beings are, in virtue of their creation as men and women.

"It is crucially important that the two or three passages which silence and suppress women are understood in their original context. On the one hand, they need to be related to the context of the specific churches Paul is writing to. That context was one of disorder and doctrinal confusion, to which certain women were contributing disproportionately. Paul reins in these women in order to deal with the problem of chaos and confusion, not because he was opposed in principle to the public ministry of women."

Those who apply those two or three passages restrictively, beyond the original context which occasioned their writing, do not believe them to be about suppression, or opposition in principle to all public ministry of women. Such words represent straw men. The issue is over what roles are proper in the public ministry of women.

To be sure, the original context must be taken into account. For example, there are indications that Paul's letters to Timothy were precipitated in part by problems at Ephesus. False teaching was sowing dissension, promoting ignorance and triviality (1 Tim 1:3-7; 6:4-5; 2 Tim 2:14), and encouraging ascetic attitudes to food and marriage (1 Tim 4:1-3).

The application of 1 Tim 2:11-15 might therefore be limited to the situation then current at Ephesus. If this is so, however, we should expect to find some reference to these problems in 2:11-15, but we do not. As Douglass Moo writes in the concluding remarks of his
analysis of the passage:

In the case of 1 Timothy 2:12, none of the factors that we have considered above, nor any of the many others that have been proposed (women were not educated enough to teach; Jews would have been offended by it; etc.) is stated, or even hinted at, in the text. (p. 187)


It should be obvious that one way to respond to a problematic situation in a local, time bound context is to appeal to a binding, enduring, universal principle. Whether or not 1 Tim 2:8-15 was provoked by problems at Ephesus, Paul does in fact appeal to a binding, enduring, universal principle. More on this in part three.

Continuing with Marshall:

"Too often 1 Cor 14:34-36 and 1 Tim 2:8-15 are taken as the apostle's definitive position on the ministry of women, without any reference to Paul's explicit affirmations of gender equality elsewhere in his writings,4 or to the evidence that in his own missionary praxis Paul esteemed women as colleagues of equal standing as men."

Marshall's reference is again to Gal 3:28, equivocating on the notion of equality (see above). There is an obvious reason why these texts are taken as definitive for the ministry of women. In contrast to Gal 3:28, they are
specifically about the ministry of women.

By comparison, his evidence, which largely consists of Paul's positive references in greeting a number of NT women, is peripheral to the subject. (I don't mean to dismiss of the importance of these women.) His starting point is in Romans 16:

(i)
Phoebe

"[V]ery probably", she brought Paul's letter to the Romans. That doesn't seem to be an unreasonable assumption.

"It is not an insignificant detail that Paul entrusted his magnum opus ... to a woman to deliver to the Roman church. Phoebe's task would not only have been physically to carry the letter to Rome but also to read it to the congregations there and to offer any explanation of Paul's meaning where that was necessary - effectively a teaching role."

What began as very probable was unaccountably just promoted to a factual detail. And beyond that, it simply begs the question that a woman delivering Paul's epistle would also function in such a teaching role.

"Phoebe was also a leader (diakonos) in the church at Cenchreae. The word diakonos seems to designate here a recognised leadership office in the congregation which, in light of the way the same term is used elsewhere in the Pauline literature, probably included a teaching and preaching function.6"

Phoebe was a deaconess,
diakonos meaning most generally a minister or servant while also used to designate a recognised church office (1 Tim 3:8-13). The functions of that office, however, are not specifically geared towards leadership or teaching. The fact that some whom Paul calls ministers or servants would have ruling or teaching authority is attributable to the generality of the term diakonos - obviously a ruling or teaching elder is one who serves or ministers (e.g. Rom 15:8; 1 Cor 3:5; 1 Tim 4:6). So it again begs the question to infer that Phoebe's servanthood role included leading, teaching or preaching.

(ii)
Priscilla

"Priscilla ... and her husband Aquila are the best known missionary couple in the early church. ... [I]n four of the six references to the pair in the New Testament, Priscilla is mentioned before her husband, perhaps suggesting she had the more impressive public presence.8"

Granting all that, nothing follows concerning Priscilla's role in the gathered body of the church.

"Both had a notable teaching ministry,9 and both shared leadership of house churches in Corinth, Ephesus and Rome. Paul speaks of the "church in their house", not in Aquila's home, as ancient convention prescribed.10"

The notable teaching ministry cited is their instruction of Apollos (Acts 18:26). Even if Priscilla did most of the talking, they did it together, privately, not in a congregational setting. The NT is silent about the leadership in their house churches, (but does lay down a standard for Aquila in that regard (1 Tim 3:4-5)).

(iii)
Junia(s)

According to Marshall, the Junia(s) of Rom 16:7 should be translated Junia, which is a woman’s name. Junia is said to be noted among the apostles and a believer before Paul. Therefore she has a clear teaching role and belongs to that limited group which is authoritative in the sense of Eph 2:20.

In response, Rom 16:7 has other translation problems besides the disputed "Junias" (NASB, NIV, RSV) vs. "Junia" (ESV, NKJV). Junia(s) might instead be "well known to the apostles" (ESV, NKJV, corresponding to "Junia"), rather than "among the apostles", and "apostles" could be translated more broadly as "messengers", (cf. John 13:16; 2 Cor 8:23; Phil 2:25). So no solid ground is here afforded for the egalitarian position.

(iv)
Mary, Tryphaena, Tryphosa, Persis

The claim is that Mary, Tryphaena, Tryphosa and Persis are women identified by a term which indicates they perform hard missionary work (Rom 16:6, 12). Such work involved preaching, teaching (cf. Acts 15:35), and the exercise of authority (1 Thess 5:12-13; 1 Cor 16:16).

But nothing in the context of the proof texts (Acts 15:35; 1 Thess 5:12-13; 1 Cor 16:16) indicates that women were involved in those activities. Thus, it is simply being assumed that the hard missionary work of a woman is no different from the hard missionary work of a man.

(v)
Euodia and Syntyche

"There is no hint that these women had a subordinate role to Paul or to male workers like Clement; on the contrary, Paul's language stresses their equality."


As Paul provides no specifics regarding the ministry roles of these women (Phil 4:2-3), there's nothing here to move the balance one way or the other. Their "names are in the book of life" (v. 3) - this being the real guarantee of their essential equality, rather than their roles in the church.

"They are not explicitly identified as leaders ..."

Hardly a novel deficiency in the character of the data presented by Marshall thus far.

(vi)
Apphia, Nympha, Chloe

Apphia and Nympha are women greeted in Paul's epistles, Apphia being associated with Philemon's house (Phl 2), and Nympha possessing a house (Col 4:5), which to the mind of some egalitarians seems enough to suggest house church leadership.

Marshall neglects to observe that "Nympha" is possibly a man, "Nymphas" (ESV).

A similar conclusion concerning Chloe allegedly follows because certain people associated with her name, and therefore supposedly sent by her, inform Paul about quarrels (1 Cor 1:11-12). Each one is saying "I am of Paul", and "I am of Apollos", and "I am of Cephas", and "I am of Christ". Why none "of Chloe", if she is a leader and they are prone to such factionalism?


Summary

Indications of specific ministry roles are unduly read into the language of Paul's greetings to women, and it seems like partiality towards women of means to assume that they have leading roles, in the gathered body, in house churches with which their names are connected.

The failure of Marshall's article is the failure to fulfill its programmatic subheading,
On Reading Paul in Context. A paradigm furnished through an eisegesis of Gal 3:28 is in effect the interpretive lens for verses from contexts foreign to both Gal 3 and to the controversy at hand. On the other hand, those texts which are most directly relevant to the controversy, which logically would be expected to be "in the dock" to answer the charge of "sexism", are left virtually untouched.

I will examine those texts (1 Cor 14:33b-35; 1 Tim 2:8-15) in part three.

1 comment: