In their debate, William Lane Craig ably parried the two-pronged assault of Peter Atkins aimed at explaining away and dismissing belief in God, as if it amounted (in a sense) to an argument against the existence of God.
Atkins: [i] ...you don't need, actually, a god ... science can account for everything ... science is omnipotent .... [ii] people like you desperately want to believe in God.
Craig: But two fallacious arguments put together don't make a sound argument, right?
Craig dealt with [ii] early on in the three minute clip. Even if it were true, which Craig doesn't for a minute admit, Atkins would be committing the genetic fallacy in drawing his desired conclusion.
As for [i], what can't science account for? Craig was only too glad to be asked, get more comfortable in his seat, and give Atkins a schooling.
Among the things which cannot be scientifically proven but that we are all rational to accept are these five:
(1) Logical and mathematical truths. They are presupposed by science, so to try to prove them by science would be to argue in a circle.
(2) Metaphysical truths, e.g. the existence of other minds, the reality of the external world, and that the world was not created five minutes ago with the appearance of age are scientifically unprovable, rational beliefs.
(3) Ethical beliefs about statements of value are not accessible by the scientific method.
(4) Aesthetic judgments cannot be accessed by the scientific method – the beautiful, like the good, cannot be scientifically proven.
(5) Science itself, most remarkably, cannot be justified by the scientific method. It is permeated with unprovable assumptions.
Apropos (5), science relies on inductive reasoning, which cannot be justified in an atheistic universe. The Christian, on the other hand, can account for the uniformity of nature, and therefore the legitimacy of induction, because he knows that God is at the helm controlling all things.
No comments:
Post a Comment