Some people have too much time on their hands, it would seem, given the nature of some kinds of speculative material on the web. Take, for instance, attempts to infer the denominational affiliations of fictional characters, based on scattered and inconclusive evidence from fictional works.
Adherents.com tries to discern the religious persuasion of well known public figures, the degree of certainty in the conclusions depending on the quality of evidence in the public record. But the persuasions of oddball celebrities are surely of trifling importance as compared with the alleged convictions of those characters of greater heft and influence, Batman and Superman.
Growing up, I loved to escape into the universe of DC Comics. First, Superman was my hero, and then later, Batman, and so actually I have to admit some appreciation for the effort that has gone into their respective pages at adherents.com.
Clark Kent was raised by his foster parents as a Methodist. Though not a churchgoer, it seems he has definite sympathies there, while also being influenced by the monotheistic religion of his home world, Krypton. Bruce Wayne comes from a Christian family, but has lapsed from the religious practice of his parents. Probably they were Episcopalian or Roman Catholic, or perhaps a mixture: an Episcopalian father and a Catholic mother.
Superman is more open to spiritual ideas than Batman. (At one point Clark marries Lois Lane in what is clearly a Christian marriage ceremony.) His origination from another planet and reception of post-mortem instruction from his biological father in his temple-like "Fortress of Solitude" would tend to broaden Superman's mind, I daresay. He is willing to entertain mystical explanations for hard to explain events.
Batman, although he has studied Eastern religious practices and mysticism, is for the most part a hard-boiled rational empiricist for whom all explanation must reduce to a materialistic mode - stubborn cases of the unexplained must await their solution in terms of a reductionistic science of the future. His spiritual beliefs are actually hard to determine precisely, as they have tended to shift over time, between agnostic or atheist, and Christian.
Bruce Wayne's parents were gunned down before his eyes as a young boy. Hugely formative for his psyche, maybe a lack of an adequate theodicy for this event feeds his more sceptical inclinations.
What was the reason behind my switch of preference from Superman to Batman, as a youngster?
Look at Superman - what did he ever have to do to prepare himself as a crime fighter? As a superhuman, he's not competing on a level playing field against other humans. He just falls back on his natural, unearned ability. Expose him to kryptonite or pit him against a worthy superhuman foe, and then he doesn't look so extraordinary.
In contrast, Batman is highly trained. He spent years in preparation to be the best he can be. It's true that Bruce Wayne inherited great wealth and can afford a lot of hi-tech gadgetry, but he has the knowledge and skills both to run his business empire and to operate a scientifically advanced crime lab. He is highly intelligent, athletic, and unsurpassed as a martial artist, having honed those skills in the Orient - Sherlock Holmes and Bruce Lee in single package. Add into the mix his vengeful streak, and we have...
Batman Contra Mundum

I admired Batman for all his self accomplishment. All the other superheroes had special powers of one kind or another, yet Batman attained to their league through sheer human prowess. I would have been proud to have been able to emulate such a pinnacle in the development of human potential.
Basically, I came to prefer Batman over Superman because of his appeal to the pride of my sinful nature. For unregenerate human beings, man is the measure of all things. The sinful nature desires self-aggrandisement, independently of the Creator. Batman - the Dark Knight - was an idol through whom I experienced vicarious pride, while taking pleasure in the darker side of the personality.
There's nothing intrinsically wrong with Batman having developed his abilities. That can still be admired, but all the glory needs to go to God.
To Superman, however, I owe an apology. With no intention of giving overall endorsement to the film Kill Bill, Vol. 2, I cite from there the first two or so minutes of monologue from the following clip as having provoked a re-evaluation of Superman.
We shouldn't think less of Superman for having his super attributes essentially rather than contingently. They can be appreciated as good in themselves, as deriving from God, to whom be the glory. (Reality check: I speak of an alternate world in which God created the Kryptonians, similarly, perhaps, to the angels.) No matter what Batman makes of himself, he'll never be able to do as much good for the world as Superman. Superman can save entire continents, or the whole planet, from almost any kind of threat - natural, human or alien - and has even rescued Batman from a few tight spots as well.
Superman's vulnerability to kryptonite functions as a useful plot device, to give his adversaries more of a fighting chance, but it is also one of the crosses he bears for choosing to live with humankind. In fact, further consideration of Superman's non-essential traits reveals further cross bearing.
He lives with us in great humility, never using his superior abilities for his personal advantage. He must exercise restraint and gentleness in his physical interactions with humans, whether friends or foes, lest he crush them like bugs. Frequently the shield he places between the public and lethal threats to them is his own body. In his "earthly ministry" he demands no privileged status for serving us, and is willing to play by human rules. His mission is in accordance with the wishes of his true father, Jor-El.
Superman is Christ-like. Batman appeals in terms of works-righteousness.
It can't be ruled out that Bruce Wayne will be reunited with his slain parents. I hope for him to be encouraged by his old friend into transcending the limitations of his worldview, and, from the vestiges that remain, to have revived within himself that uniquely Christian hope, of the resurrection and the life....