Thursday, April 29, 2010

Gender ordered ministry, part 3

In part one of this series I took note of the various and valuable ways that women in the early church served God and his people. In part two my object was to demonstrate the failure, in the case of a representative article, of question begging attempts to press Scripture to exemplify women in ruling or teaching roles in the church and thereby to relativise to time, place or situation those texts which restrict such roles to men. In this final part I let the restrictive texts speak in full Biblical context, focusing primarily on 1 Timothy 2:8-15. First:


1 Corinthians 14:33b-35 (ESV)

As in all the churches of the saints, 34 the women should keep silent in the churches. For they are not permitted to speak, but should be in submission, as the Law also says. 35 If there is anything they desire to learn, let them ask their husbands at home. For it is shameful for a woman to speak in church.

For the following reasons these verses should command our attention for possible application to the contemporary church.

(i) They are in the relevant context, that of orderly public worship (v. 26, 40).
(ii) They apply not just locally in Corinth, but to all the churches.
(iii) There is an appeal to OT Scripture (the Law).
(iv) They are a command of the Lord (v. 37).

At face value this is pretty conclusive: women are to be silent in the worship of the church (as individuals, presumably). Actually, stepping back and taking in the preceding context, which is the weighing of prophecies (vv. 29 ff.), the prohibition is unlikely to be so rigid. Thus, it would be prohibition from participation in the oral weighing of prophecies which would be in view (see
D.A. Carson, pp. 142-143).

Carson thinks the Law (v. 34) probably refers to the creation order of Gen 2:20b-24. For Gen 2 lays down a pattern of submission, at least between husband and wife, and Paul already connected his thinking with this pattern in 1 Cor 11 - woman was created from man and for man, and so is under male headship (11:3, 8-10). This pattern could not be preserved if wives were to participate in the weighing of their husbands' prophesying.

1 Cor 11 shows also that there is a context in which a woman (or wife) may pray or prophesy (v. 5). Further, we might think the prohibition to be moot in so far as prophesying has ostensibly ceased in this age.

At the very least, however, 1 Cor 14:33b-35 disproves the egalitarian notion of there being no gender based role distinctions in the worship of the church. Very probably this is by reason of the created order, a grounding which explicitly comes to the fore in the more pointed and universal prohibitions of 1 Tim 2:8-15.


1 Timothy 2:8-15 (ESV)

I desire then that in every place the men should pray, lifting holy hands without anger or quarreling; 9 likewise also that women should adorn themselves in respectable apparel, with modesty and self-control, not with braided hair and gold or pearls or costly attire, 10 but with what is proper for women who profess godliness—with good works. 11 Let a woman learn quietly with all submissiveness. 12 I do not permit a woman to teach or to exercise authority over a man; rather, she is to remain quiet. 13 For Adam was formed first, then Eve; 14 and Adam was not deceived, but the woman was deceived and became a transgressor. 15 Yet she will be saved through childbearing—if they continue in faith and love and holiness, with self-control.

Here are some salient points concerning the scope of the passage.

(i) Verses 1-7 establish the whole sphere of humanity as the global context into which verses 8-15 speak: prayers, and so on, are to be for people of all kinds of social status (vv. 1-2); God's saving will is towards all kinds; Christ is the only mediator for all (v. 5); the only ransom for all (v. 6); whence the preaching of the gospel extends beyond Jewry to people of all ethnicities by way of Paul's mission to the Gentiles.

(ii) In verse 8 Paul makes a logical connection between the preceding global context and his instructions for conduct in worship "in every place", i.e. globally.

(iii) The "likewise also" of v. 9 indicates that the instructions of vv. 8-12 which pertain to women are for women "in every place" no less than the instructions for men are for men "in every place".

(iv) Adam and Eve (vv. 13-14) are paradigmatic of the entirety of humanity, and verse 13 references them in their prelapsarian state. Theologically, this provides the strongest of grounds to see the prohibitions of vv. 11-12 as universal in scope, transcending all cultural conditions, not accommodated to our fallenness but rooted in the creation order.

The activities involved in 1 Timothy 2:12 are, by definition, transcultural in the sense that they are permanent ministries of the Christian church, and the prohibitions of 1 Timothy 2:12 are grounded in theology. When we add to these factors the fact that the New Testament teaching on these matters is consistent ..., we are justified in requiring very good reasons from the text itself to limit the application of this text in any way. We find no such reasons. Therefore, we must conclude that the restrictions imposed by Paul in 1 Timothy 2:12 are valid for Christians in all places and all times [Douglass Moo, pp. 187-188, my emphasis].

(v) Coordinated with Paul's desire for "every place" (v. 8) is his reason for writing the whole of 2:8-3:13 - that "you may know how one ought to behave in the household of God" (3:15). The applicability of the restrictions of vv. 11-12 are no less enduring than the qualifications for elders and deacons.

Prima facie v. 12 prohibits women from teaching and leadership roles. As preaching to a congregation necessarily involves teaching and carries with it a level of authority, neither would Paul allow a woman to preach. (He places preaching under the rubric of teaching in v. 7.)


Attempts to Circumvent 1 Timothy 2:12

Already in
part two I noted, with support from Moo, the absence in 2:8-15 of any appeal to factors possibly in play at Ephesus which objectors have proposed in order to explain away or mitigate for us the force of Paul's prohibitions. Nevertheless, it seems worthwhile to flush out some of the more commonly raised objections to the plain sense of 2:12 to see how well they fare under fire. They are numbered (i)-(iii) with my responses under each.

(i)
The verse doesn't apply to women in general, but only to wives in relation to their husbands. So the way is open for women to be teachers or leaders in the church.

(a) Women in general are in view in vv. 9-10. It would break with the context if vv. 11-12 concerned women only as wives.

(b) The husband of a woman would likely be a member of the congregation to which she preached and so would receive her teaching. Obviously that would be unworkable under the given interpretation of v. 12.

(c) Though it is possible from the Greek terms, I am not aware of any English translation which renders v. 12 with "wife" and "husband". Translators apparently recognise that would not fit the context.

(ii)
The meaning of authentein, to "exercise authority", is actually to "lord it over", "domineer" or "usurp authority". So it's fine for a woman to teach or rule in the church, just so long as she doesn't do it abusively.

(a) Abusively over men, the verse would then actually be saying. So would it be fine for her to domineer the women? Why single out men as those over whom such authority is an abuse?

(b) Even if Paul did have usurpation in mind (cf. KJV), that could be taken as an indication of his horror at such a practice - the taking of such authority being by definition usurpatious, as an assault against the created order, for "Adam was formed first" (v. 13).

(c) The word occurs in the NT here only, and lexical studies have been conducted to try to determine its in meaning in wider usage.

Debate surrounding the meaning of authentein in 1 Timothy 2:12 has focused on whether the term is to be viewed as a general or positive concept, with no pejorative connotation, or whether it has a negative or pejorative meaning (such as “domineer”). The research of those who have examined in detail all the evidence now available to us shows that the predominant meaning of authentein in the Greek-speaking world during the time of Jesus and Paul was the non-pejorative or positive meaning “to exercise authority over.” (Lutheran Church - Missouri Synod, CTCR Report, 2005)

In the Commission’s view the English Standard Version accurately translates 1 Timothy 2:12: “I do not permit a woman to teach or to
exercise authority over a man; rather, she is to remain quiet.” (Ibid., bold in original)

(iii)
Paul has a particular heretical woman in mind. He doesn't mean to put a bar on women who teach sound doctrine.

(a) The rest of 2:1-3:13 deals with groups: people in general, men, women, elders/overseers, deacons. Reference to an unnamed woman would be out of step with this context and also with Paul's willingness to name particular false teachers (1 Tim 1:20; 2 Tim 2:17).

(b) Why, as the verse would then be saying, is it only men over whom heretical teaching is a problem? Is it okay for this woman to teach heresy to other women?

(c) Paul would want to completely silence a heretical teacher, not simply want her to become more quiet. But the word he uses for quiet in vv. 11-12 is
hesuchia, which means "to become subdued or more quiet" (cf. Acts 22:2; 2 Thess 3:12), not sigao, meaning "to be completely silent" (Luke 20:26; Acts 12:17; 15:12, 13; Rom 16:25; 1 Cor 14:28, 30, 34).

(d) Writing to Timothy, Paul has a term for "to teach falsely",
heterodidaskaleo (1 Tim 1:3; 6:3), which is not used in 2:12. Rather, consistent with its other uses in the context of sound teaching, the term he uses for "to teach" is didasko (cf. 1 Tim 4:11; 6:2; 2 Tim 2:2).

(e) The evidence is against an individual false teacher being the subject of v. 12. Similar considerations would weigh against it having reference to a succession of heretical women coming into the church.

The
prima facie reading of 1 Tim 2:12 must therefore stand. It has application not just to a woman who is domineering or heretical, but precludes any woman from teaching or leading in a church assembly where both genders are present.


Adam first

Paul's reasoning for 1 Tim 2:11-12 is all important.

13 For Adam was formed first, then Eve; 14 and Adam was not deceived, but the woman was deceived and became a transgressor.

On other occasions when Paul mentions Adam it's because his subject is one of very deep significance (Rom 5:12 ff.; 1 Cor 15:21-22, 45-49). We therefore should not overlook the importance of Adam - the head of mankind - in Paul's reasoning here.

Adam was created
first. That's akin to primogeniture. Strictly speaking, it's not of chronological import, but bears on the responsibilities accorded to Adam rather than Eve.

From the beginning, in Genesis 2, before Eve was created, God gave Adam responsibility over his theocratic realm on earth - the garden - to work it and keep it. To Adam alone was given the ethical instruction to not eat of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil, and the consequences for so doing; to him alone the allowance to eat of every other tree of the garden, including the tree of life, which had a sacramental significance. Adam would have fulfilled priestly and prophetic roles in passing on these instructions to Eve. By allowing him to name the beasts and birds brought to him, God was showing Adam his dominion over them. Thus, in naming "Woman", Adam is shown to be her head.

(Similarly Christ is the head of the church; Adam's deep sleep and awakening pictures Christ's death and resurrection while Eve is a picture Christ's spiritual offspring; Adam's side brought forth Eve while the piercing of Christ's side confirmed his death which brought us forth to new life (cf. Eph 5:23).)

I'm skipping over those parts of Gen 1-2 which make clear the essential equality of man and woman, (e.g. the value of Eve implicit in the term "helper"), but to sum up, likening man and woman in their unity to a mathematical point represented by a coordinate pair, the indexical coordinate is man. As Adam was first, (and as God reveals himself as masculine in personhood), the heralds of God's word are to be men.

"Adam was not deceived, but the woman was deceived..." (v. 14) - which makes sense in Paul's argument only if in general men are by design less prone to deception than women, and hence are the ones intended to handle the word of God, in guarding the flock against the evil one. This agrees with our experience: men tend to be more the sticklers for doctrine, more dispositionally suited to denounce heresy and to deliver words of exhortation; women are more relationally oriented, more willing to trust, to see only the good and not rock the boat. The masculine qualities are called for (Titus 1:9-10) in the pulpit more so than the feminine.


Redemptive History

To reiterate, the above considerations pertain to Adam and Eve in their prelapsarian state. It cannot be argued, therefore, that the preference for having men in teaching, leading and headship roles is a result solely of cultural prejudice or is an accommodation to our fallenness on the part of the Biblical authors.

On the contrary, according to Gen 3:16, it is the curse which gives rise to the impulse to overthrow male headship: "Your desire shall be for your husband, and he shall rule over you". In Gen 4:7 is the single other occurrence in the Torah of the Hebrew term here used for "desire". The verse reveals clearly the subversive meaning: "...sin is crouching at the door. Its desire is for you, but you must rule over it". Just as sin desired to subvert Cain, the woman would desire to subvert the legitimate rule of the man. (Admittedly fallen men rule abusively in many cases.)

But the plan of redemption, it could be objected, promises better things than a return to the conditions of the original paradise. Doesn't Gal 3:28 say that in Christ there is neither male or female? (See
part two for discussion of how this verse is misapplied.) Yes, better things are to come, but the indications of redemptive history are against any flattening out of gender roles in the new creation. Jesus, the twelve he chose as disciples, those he appointed as apostles, the writers of the NT - all are men. The picture is the same in the eschatological church: the twelve will sit on thrones judging the tribes of Israel (Mat 19:28); and in the New Jerusalem, on the gates are the names of the tribes of the sons of Israel, and on the foundations are the names of the apostles of the Lamb (Rev 21:12-14). An egalitarian trajectory cannot be established.


Conclusion

There is no blanket restriction on women as teachers. The restrictions function in the context of the assembled church (1 Tim 2:8-10). A woman may teach a man in some situations (Acts 18:26), and may be called to teach other women (Titus 2:3-4). A woman is prohibited from taking on the teaching, preaching or ruling functions which are typically the province of an elder or pastor.

Those who accept this traditional, conservative interpretation should appreciate and encourage women in ministry, and ensure that their views are based on exegesis rather than prejudice or tradition. That goes both ways, of course. Is the egalitarian view purely exegetical, or is it mainly influenced by a secular spirit of the age?

I suspect the latter. It seems incredible otherwise for so many words to have been exchanged in argument over what was obvious to Christian orthodoxy, from Scripture,
until the 19th century.


Further reading:
John MacArthur, The Biblical Position on Women's Roles
John Piper & Wayne Grudem, eds., Recovering Biblical Manhood and Womanhood: A Response to Evangelical Feminism
Wayne Grudem,
Systematic Theology: An Introduction to Biblical Doctrine (Leicester: IVP, 1994)

1 comment: